June 2010 Archives

June 25, 2010

Metro Atlanta Charter Bus Accident ends in Traumatic Brain Injury

A 28 year old former DeKalb police officer finally settled his case with the insurer for a charter bus that collided with his truck in heavy rain in Hall County. The young officer was off-duty at the time that he lost control of his vehicle on I-85 and slammed into the median wall - his truck was protruding into the HOV lane in which a charter bus was travelling that crashed into him shortly thereafter. Because of the traumatic brain injury (TBI), the young man is no longer able to work suffering from loss of vision and brain damage. The insurer ultimately settled for $5 million after evidence was uncovered that the bus driver was travelling 6 miles over the limit.

In Georgia, charter bus drivers must have a commercial license and operate under different rules and requirements. However, more than speed was at play in this settlement. Insurers must look at the whole case, the county in which the case will be heard, and the "sympathy factor" for the plaintiff. In this case a young police officer with a family was a very sympathetic victim. Looking at just the facts, the bus driver was caught unaware on a dark, rainy night as he came upon the truck in the HOV lane. The fact that he was speeding established at least some negligence on his part.

Additionally, the type of injury suffered by this young man - traumatic brain injury - requires specialized knowledge and expert testimony. As someone with a family member who suffered a severe head injury resulting in permanent brain damage, I can tell you that the nuances of this type of injury require skill and understanding to be able to communicate to a jury (or insurance lawyers) the full impact of TBI.

Continue reading "Metro Atlanta Charter Bus Accident ends in Traumatic Brain Injury" »

June 21, 2010

One Car, Four Trucks - August, Georgia Accident

At a glance, four trucks and one car make for a great damages case - but liability (or negligence) is the first issue to address. As is common in the metro Atlanta area, rain was a factor in this semi-truck accident. A jury recently returned a verdict for the four trucks involved in a multi-vehicle accident on I-20 in Augusta, Georgia. The reason? A flustered plaintiff on the witness stand.

What appeared to be a sure win for the plaintiff took a turn for the worse when he became flustered on the stand and began to agree with the defense attorneys regarding the location of his car, the speed he was traveling, and the location of the trucks involved. Witness preparation is an important aspect of case preparation in any trial attorney's arsenal. Generally it includes role-playing where the witness is cross-examined by one of his attorneys and asked tough questions in order to give him an idea of what may come while he is on the witness stand. More complex issues or witnesses who lack confidence may benefit from a session or two with a psychologist.

Further, truck accidents require special knowledge of the many federal regulations the truck drivers and their trucks operate under. For example, every year trucking companies must make sure their drivers are still qualified to drive a commercial vehicle.

Continue reading "One Car, Four Trucks - August, Georgia Accident" »

June 15, 2010

$350,000 Jury Award in DeKalb Car Accident Case

While it was undisputed that the defendant caused the accident, a plaintiff had her work cut out for her it convincing a DeKalb County jury that the back injury she suffered was caused by the accident. The 46-year-old woman suffered spine injury and disc compression in the car accident. However, one of the elements in a personal injury case such as this is proving causation. Using medical records, expert physician testimony, and testimony of family and friends is often the most logical way to prove causation.

As trial attorneys, we often use all of the above to prove causation. Most important are the medical records which can show the timing and course of treatment. In this case, the woman did not visit a physician until two months after her original emergency room visit after the accident. Because back injuries can show up gradually, an experienced attorney will be prepared to "connect the dots."

Continue reading "$350,000 Jury Award in DeKalb Car Accident Case" »

June 1, 2010

$1.29 Million Awarded to Injured Motorist in DeKalb County

A motorist involved in a trucking accident in DeKalb County, Georgia suffered severe injuries to his arm and can no longer work. Under a law that had been created to close a loophole that could allow out-of-state trucking companies to escape liability, the jury was allowed to consider the direct liability of the South Carolina trucking company.

Generally Georgia law protects insurers from being named in lawsuits with those they insure because disclosure of insurance coverage can be highly prejudicial. However, the Direct Action Statute at O.C.G.A. 46-7-12 does permit such lawsuits. The statute requires in-state trucking companies to file certificates of insurance with the Public Service Commission. Because there is no such governance for out-of-state companies the legislature allowed direct action against trucking companies in the law.

Continue reading "$1.29 Million Awarded to Injured Motorist in DeKalb County" »